When Little Big Town’s Karen Fairchild, Kimberly Schlapman, Phillip Sweet and Jimi Westbrook stopped by morning show Ty, Kelly & Chuck to talk about their bright new single, “Summer Fever,” the foursome had no idea the conversation would take such a dark turn.

But it did.

If Karen, Kimberly, Phillip and Jimi were stranded on a deserted island together, who would they eat first?

“We’ve always talked about that with the band—who would we eat?” says Karen. “Kimberly would probably taste like cinnamon or something yummy—sweet like a cupcake or a cookie.”

“I would taste like special brownies,” added Phillip.

“[Phillip] might should be first, ’cause at least you’d [be happy], never mind,” says Jimi.

I guess we’ll have to wait and see if they eat Kimberly or Phillip first. In the meantime, Little Big Town will join forces with Miranda Lambert for a co-headlining tour this summer. The Bandwagon Tour will kick off on July 12 in Charlotte, N.C., and make stops in Cincinnati, Indianapolis, Tampa, Philadelphia, Toronto and more.

Watch LBT discuss who is their tastiest member below.